MemeadorProduct design collective← AI visibility
Published baseline · first run 2026-09-14 · re-run 2026-10-07

What AI says about our own product

Before we run this for anyone else, we publish the same test on ourselves. This is the unedited result: our product, Is This Page Good, across nine AI engines: which recognise it, which describe it wrongly, and which have never heard of it.

Why publish this: the honest first step is finding out you're not on the list. Most vendors show a dashboard and hide the misses. We'd rather show the misses — including the ones where an engine describes our product as something it isn't, which is as damaging as silence.

Method

18 prompts per engine: 15 unbranded (a buyer asking for a page-review or landing-page-audit tool, never naming us) and 3 branded (asking directly about Is This Page Good). Cold sessions, no account history, no search pre-seeding. Each answer recorded verbatim and scored for (a) whether we were named unbranded, (b) whether the description was correct.

The result

EngineNamed unbrandedBranded recallDescribed correctly?
Inkling (Thinking Machines)2 of 153 of 3No — called it “professional critiques, not automated scores”
Inkling-small03 of 3No — misread the mechanism as “peer feedback”
Gemini 3.6 Flash0NamedYes — accurate description
DeepSeek Chat00 of 3Never heard of it
GLM 5.3 Flash0Name only“No knowledge”
Nex 2.5 Pro0Name only“Can't verify”
Laguna S 2.1~11 of 15 (flagged)—Anomaly — pending re-probe

Baseline run 2026-09-14. Rows marked “flagged”/“anomaly” are excluded from the headline rate until re-probed.

Where it stands now — three weeks in

We re-ran the same eighteen questions on 2026-10-07, about three weeks after the run above — same questions, plus ChatGPT, which wasn't in the first run.

EngineKnows the nameDescribes it correctly?Named unprompted
ChatGPT3 of 3Yes0 of 15
Perplexity3 of 3Yes0 of 15
Claude3 of 3Yes0 of 15
Gemini3 of 3Yes0 of 15

Re-run 2026-10-07. GLM and Laguna repeated the name but stated no knowledge of it; Gemma was unavailable. The original panel's smaller experimental models are partly retired, so this is the same eighteen questions on the engines that still run — plus ChatGPT.

What moved: three weeks ago, of the engines that knew the name, most described it wrong — a peer-review community, “professional critiques, not automated scores.” Today the four engines that matter describe it accurately: an AI landing-page audit tool from Memeador, a free report, about ninety seconds.

What hasn't changed: when nobody asks our name, we're still not in the answer. That part is earned off-site, over months — which is exactly what the sprint is for.

What it says

We'll run the same test on you.

Three real buyer questions, the answers verbatim, and the competitor named instead of you. Free.

Get the free mirror test →